Antipsychotic Medications and Dementia: Exploring Safer Alternatives 

The reliance on antipsychotic medications in dementia treatment is becoming a contentious issue, eliciting warnings from researchers and healthcare professionals across the dementia ecosphere. These medications are frequently administered to manage the behavioral and psychological symptoms associated with dementia, such as agitation, aggression, and psychosis. However, recent studies and expert opinions suggest that these medications, while sometimes necessary, are often overprescribed, leading to severe health risks for vulnerable older adults.

Understanding Dementia-Related Behavioral Issues

Dementia, including Alzheimer’s disease and other related disorders, profoundly impacts cognitive function, often leading to significant behavioral changes in affected individuals. As dementia progresses, patients may exhibit increased agitation, aggression, and even psychosis. These behavioral symptoms can be challenging for caregivers and healthcare providers to manage, particularly in home healthcare settings.

Agitation in older adults living with dementia can manifest in various ways, from restlessness and fidgeting to more severe behaviors like attempting to leave the house or becoming verbally or physically aggressive. Such symptoms are often distressing for both patients and their caregivers, contributing to a high level of caregiver burden and stress. Aggression, which may arise in the mid to late stages of dementia, often results from the frustration of losing the ability to perform daily activities independently​.

The Role of Antipsychotic Drugs in Managing Symptoms

Given the challenging nature of these symptoms, antipsychotic drugs are sometimes prescribed to help manage and mitigate these behaviors. These medications can have a calming effect, reducing agitation and aggression, and are often used as a short-term solution during acute episodes of behavioral disturbances. For example, antipsychotics might be prescribed following an injury or illness that has exacerbated confusion and delirium in a dementia patient​.

However, the use of antipsychotic medications in dementia care is fraught with significant risks. These drugs are associated with serious adverse outcomes, including increased risks of stroke, heart failure, pneumonia, and sudden cardiac death. The potential for these severe side effects necessitates a cautious approach to prescribing these medications​.

Dr. David Merrill, a geriatric psychiatrist, underscores that antipsychotics should not be the first-line treatment for behavioral problems in dementia. He emphasizes the importance of regularly assessing the need for these medications and considering their discontinuation when possible. “Often, they are rightly prescribed in the hospital after an injury or illness for delirium and confusion, and then they are continued at home. The patient may need support at home, but not more medication,” Merrill explains​.

The Extent of Overprescription

Despite the risks, antipsychotic medications are often overprescribed to older adults living with dementia. A study published in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society found that older adults with Alzheimer’s disease or related dementias receiving home healthcare were more than twice as likely to be prescribed antipsychotics compared to those without dementia (17% versus 6%). This trend highlights the need for improved prescribing practices and the exploration of safer, non-pharmacological interventions​.

Risks and Adverse Outcomes

The overuse of antipsychotic medications in dementia care is not without consequence. Research published in The BMJ highlights multiple adverse outcomes associated with these drugs, including stroke, heart failure, pneumonia, and even sudden cardiac death. The study utilized extensive data from the UK’s Clinical Practice Research Datalink, underscoring the significant health risks these medications pose to older adults living with dementia​.

Atypical antipsychotics, while commonly prescribed, pose significant dangers, particularly in older patients with dementia, increasing mortality rates and contributing to substantial health risks​.

  • Quetiapine (Seroquel): Often prescribed for schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and major depressive disorder, quetiapine is also used off-label to manage behavioral symptoms in dementia patients.
  • Risperidone (Risperdal): This medication is used to treat schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and irritability associated with autistic disorder, and is frequently prescribed to manage aggression and agitation in dementia.
  • Olanzapine (Zyprexa): Commonly prescribed for schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, olanzapine is also used off-label in dementia care to help manage severe behavioral issues.
  • Aripiprazole (Abilify): Used to treat schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and major depressive disorder, aripiprazole is sometimes prescribed to dementia patients to address psychosis and agitation.

The FDA Warning and Global Trends

In the United States, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued warnings regarding the use of atypical antipsychotics in elderly patients with dementia, citing their potential to hasten death. Despite these warnings, a significant portion of nursing home residents continues to receive these prescriptions. A 2009 World Alzheimer Report commissioned by the UK Department of Health indicated that approximately 25% of older adults living with dementia in the UK were on antipsychotic medications, reflecting a troubling trend seen across other developed countries, including Germany and Sweden​.

Alternative Approaches to Dementia Care

Given the substantial risks of antipsychotic drugs, experts suggest using non-drug approaches to manage dementia symptoms. These methods include changes to the living environment, engaging activities, and psychological therapies, which have been shown to help reduce behavioral issues without the severe side effects of medication.

  • Environmental Modifications—Changing the living environment can significantly impact a dementia patient’s behavior. For example, reducing noise and clutter can create a calmer atmosphere, which might help lessen agitation and confusion. Think about how you might feel more relaxed in a tidy, quiet room compared to a noisy, chaotic one.
  • Engaging Activities—Keeping older adults living with dementia engaged in activities they enjoy can also be very beneficial. Simple activities like listening to music, gardening, or engaging in a hobby can provide mental stimulation and reduce feelings of frustration or boredom. Imagine how engaging in a favorite hobby helps you feel more relaxed and focused; the same principle applies to those with dementia.
  • Psychological Therapies—Psychological therapies, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), can help manage symptoms like depression and anxiety, which often accompany dementia. These therapies teach coping strategies and ways to alter negative thinking patterns, which can improve mood and behavior. Just as talking to a therapist can help someone without dementia manage stress, it can also provide valuable support for older adults living with dementia.

The Alzheimer’s Association recommends several strategies to help manage agitation and aggression:

  • Offering Guided Choices: Instead of asking open-ended questions, provide two specific options. For example, “Would you like to wear the blue shirt or the green one?” This simplifies decision-making and reduces frustration.
  • Focusing on Pleasant Events: Engage the older adult in activities or conversations about things they enjoy or find comforting. For instance, talking about happy memories or involving them in a favorite pastime.
  • Using Calm, Positive Statements: Approach situations with a calm demeanor and use positive language. For example, saying “Let’s go for a walk” instead of “Don’t sit there all day.”

These non-pharmacological approaches are not only safer but often more effective in improving the quality of life for older adults living with dementia. By understanding and implementing these strategies, caregivers can better support older adults in their care, helping them live more comfortably and with greater dignity.

The Importance of Training for Caregivers

Providing caregivers and those who engage with older adults living with dementia access to specialized training is crucial in navigating the complex challenges of dementia care. Training programs equip caregivers with the skills and knowledge needed to manage behavioral and psychological symptoms effectively, reducing reliance on antipsychotic medications. Here are some benefits of such training:

  • Enhanced Understanding: Training helps caregivers understand the underlying causes of behavioral changes in older adults living with dementia, allowing them to respond with empathy and appropriate strategies rather than medication.
  • Improved Communication: Caregivers learn techniques to communicate effectively with older adults living with dementia, which can reduce agitation and frustration. Simple methods such as using calm, positive language and providing clear, guided choices can make a significant difference​.
  • Stress Reduction: Well-trained caregivers are better equipped to handle challenging behaviors, reducing their own stress and improving the overall care environment. This can lead to a more positive experience for both the caregiver and the patient.
  • Non-Pharmacological Interventions: Training programs often emphasize non-pharmacological interventions, such as engaging activities, environmental modifications, and personalized care plans. These approaches can effectively manage symptoms without the adverse effects associated with antipsychotic drugs​.
  • Better Patient Outcomes: When caregivers are equipped with the right tools and knowledge, older adults living with dementia experience better outcomes, including reduced agitation, fewer behavioral issues, and improved quality of life.

Investing in caregiver training not only enhances the care provided to older adults living with dementia but also supports the well-being and effectiveness of those who dedicate their lives to this challenging and rewarding work.

A Call for Responsible Prescribing

The persistent overprescription of antipsychotic drugs in dementia care underscores the need for more judicious use of these treatments. Glen I. Spielmans, an associate professor of psychology, argues that the current era of widespread antipsychotic use will not be remembered kindly by history. He calls for a much more cautious approach, emphasizing the importance of exploring safer, more effective alternatives before resorting to these potent medications​.

Conclusion

The overprescription of antipsychotic drugs to people living with dementia remains a critical issue, posing significant health risks and ethical concerns. While these medications may offer short-term relief for certain symptoms, their potential for harm necessitates a careful and considered approach. By prioritizing non-pharmacological interventions, providing comprehensive training for caregivers, and adhering to stringent prescribing guidelines, healthcare providers can better ensure the safety and well-being of older adults living with dementia.

As the field of dementia care continues to evolve, it is imperative that we remain vigilant in our efforts to provide compassionate, evidence-based treatment that truly enhances the quality of life for older adults living with dementia.

Resources:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest

Subscribe to our Monthly Newsletter

Get timely and relevant industry news, research and articles delivered right to your inbox each month—exclusively for those caring for & engaging with older adults. 

Never miss an upcoming publication—drop your email below and subscribe to our Newsroom.

You might like these articles, too!

Blog
Amanda Krisher, LCSW-C

When Does Old Age Begin? Unpacking the Perceptions Across Generations 

Old age is a concept deeply entrenched in societal and cultural beliefs, often varying significantly across different demographics and over time. Recent studies have illuminated these shifting perceptions, revealing that the age at which people consider themselves to be ‘old’ is steadily increasing. This article delves into the nuances of

Read More »
Blog
Amanda Krisher, LCSW-C

Nurturing Resilience: How Programs to Boost Positive Emotions are Revolutionizing Healthcare 

The COVID-19 pandemic cast a harsh light on the fragile state of mental well-being among healthcare workers. Overwhelmed by unprecedented demands, many found themselves battling burnout, anxiety, and emotional exhaustion. Amidst this crisis, innovative programs designed to boost positive emotions have emerged as critical interventions, aiming to foster resilience and

Read More »
Blog
Alysia Osoff, RN, MSN

Hypertension: A Leading Modifiable Risk Factor for Dementia 

Hypertension, commonly known as high blood pressure, has long been recognized as a significant health concern. However, recent research underscores its critical role as a modifiable risk factor for dementia, presenting both challenges and opportunities for public health interventions aimed at reducing the global burden of cognitive decline and dementia. 

Read More »

Leave a Comment

Get Articles Like this Delivered to Your Inbox Every Month

Join over 2,000 readers and sign up to never miss an upcoming publication of Engaging with Aging publication.

We respect your privacy and will never rent or sell your information to third-parties.